Of the different Vanyas I've seen, the one which remains my "benchmark" was Michael Gambon, in Michael Frayn's fresh new translation of the piece - the cast also had Jonathan Pryce as Astron (I think Roger Rees had played it earlier in the run) and Imelda Staunton. It was a production which has stuck in my mind ever since - I think, perhaps, because it realised all my expectations of what the play is "about", and how it should look and feel?
It's very dangerous to have such clear memories of shows, I think? I recently saw UNCLE VANYA here in Moscow, at the Moscow Arts Theatre (where, of course, it had originally opened). The cast included the near-legendary Oleg Tabakov as Prof Serebryakov. I'm afraid I found it all very static, and Tabakov completely inaudible - he's very old now, which was one factor... but the other was that most of the action was set within a glazed balcony of the house, and the sound got stuck behind it. I think the audience - like me - had expected a lot more than they got, especially for such expensive tickets (double the usual M.Kh.A.T. prices).
Stanley, may I ask what your view is on Chekhov's description of VANYA, THE SEAGULL etc as "comedies"? How do you interpret that title?
BTW, the most interesting Ranevskaya I ever saw in rehearsal (although the show never made it to the stage) was Josephine Barstow, directed by Keith Warner
)