Reiner, I reckon the real obstacle to period-instrument Romantic opera isn't the instruments but the singers!
I'd agree and go further - I think they are the problem with all performances of all operas
Graupner was obviously a very sensible man - writing arias for the chalumeau instead
I sympathise entirely with you, Smittims, although it sounds like you were well in advance of me on this stuff. I have always been a rotten pianist, so Keyboard Harmony remained my weakest subject, and it was a compulsory module. I even opted to take the exam at the end of my second year at Univ, on the basis that no improvement was likely during a further year, and it would just distract me from things in which I might score better marks? I was doing the obligatory "Palestrina in four clefs", and got to the end of the first "Kyrie"... I took a second to glance up, and I saw Erik Levi (who now reviews cds in Gramophone etc) banging his head on the desk... I scraped a pass-mark on the basis of my figured-bass realisation and improvised piano accompaniment.