Here's a concept which I developed for a school music class (12-13 year olds) -- it reminds me a bit of auto's suggestion -- and it
is more fun than it sounds, i.e., the concept doesn't let on how surprising the results can be. Only frustration is having to produce a bunch of index cards, though I suppose there are alternative ways of bringing about the same thing. Besides, card manufacture is less time consuming than composing a new score.
Split the class into chorus and conductors. There should be more chorus than conductors, but it could also be fun to have just one chorus member and all the rest are conductors.
The conductors do not keep time. All they do is produce sounds. As auto suggested, the action used to create the sound needs to be considered.
The chorus members each have a stack of index cards with the following information on each card:
1. the name of a conductor.
2. a method of imitating the sound that that conductor produces.
a. imitation as precise as possible
b. onomatopoetic imitation, i.e., "sproingg" or "buzz" or "thwack" or
c. singing a pitch that features prominently in the sound.
3. an instruction about the duration of the imitation. Either
a. equal in duration to the original sound
b. held (fermata) - which in the case of 2a or 2b means slowing down the imitation to ssssssppppprrrroooiiinnnnggggg. Duration of fermata ad lib or
c. repeated. # of durations and rapidity of durations ad lib.
The conductors are charged with making a few or many chosen and carefully considered sounds. The chorus members wait for the conductor listed on their card to make a sound, then they imitate that sound according to the instructions. Then they flip to the next card from their deck and await their next instruction. In the case of 3b or 3c, the previous instruction may well continue at the discretion of the chorus member until the next action is called forth.
Fun things:
A conductor who is silent for a while will often though not always produce a cascade of responses when he/she does finally utter.
An unpitched noise will result in very different opinions of what pitch is to be sung in the case of 2c
Other unexpected things ad libitum.