but how likely is it that they would be able to demonstrate equal levels of aptitude in all the different aspects (being as skilled a set designer as a composer, for example)?
To a certain extent I share your scepticism, Ian
However, there are models for it, as I hinted at in my post... Wagner not only composed the music for THE RING, but also staged it and conceived the scenery required (artists realised his conception, but strictly according to his specifications and approval). Menotti (although I wouldn't rate him alongside Wagner, perhaps) staged all of his own works (he was an accomplished stage-director in his own right, and staged many mainstream pieces - Verdi & Puccini - for La Scala and elsewhere).