The Radio 3 Boards Forum from myforum365.com
13:23:57, 02-12-2008 *
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
News: Whilst we happily welcome all genuine applications to our forum, there may be times when we need to suspend registration temporarily, for example when suffering attacks of spam.
 If you want to join us but find that the temporary suspension has been activated, please try again later.
 
   Home   Help Search Login Register  

Pages: [1] 2
  Print  
Author Topic: The buying of Hi fi Equipment  (Read 572 times)
Ron Dough
Admin/Moderator Group
*****
Posts: 5133



WWW
« on: 11:55:00, 14-10-2007 »

Most CD changers use a revolving circular tray (12 inches or so in diameter for a five disc changer, with the five CDs disposed in circular holes spaced equidistantly within the tray, which revolves to bring each disc in turn into the correct alignment for the laser to be able to read it): dropping CDs on top of each other can't be an option because the laser can't read beyond one surface. There's always a gap whilst the tray revolves and the next CD loads up, so I don't see the point: you're paying a considerable premium for mechanics which can have no positive impact on the sound quality whatsoever, and still won't bring you seamless music. Are you ever likely to sit down at home and listen regularly to more than an hour and a quarter's music without wanting to get up, have a cup of tea, find a reference book, take a leak etc? 

It's a serious consideration when anyone is contemplating buying new sound equipment, and this has been mentioned recently: in very much the same way that the big-name labels are no longer in the vanguard of recorded sound or repertoire, simply intent on producing the most profit from mass-market consumables without worrying over-much about their quality, so with most of the big audio manufacturers the actual sound quality is not the most important aspect of their product: they spend a considerable portion of the equipment's cost on advertising rather than in using better components which can have a significant impact not only on how the product sounds overall, but more importantly the level of detail it is able to portray. This may be of little relevance to those who listen to synthesised and digitally created modern music, but can make a vast difference where the nuances of human expression are concerned. If you're actually interested in music rather than being wowed by gizmology, take a look at - and much more importantly a listen to - equipment from the smaller specialists whose businesses are concerned purely with sound rather than a wide range of consumer electronics. After all, you're buying this equipment to listen through: no amount of advertising will tell you whether it will actually do the job in the way that suits you personally: buying Hi-Fi on spec. from adverts makes about as much sense as selecting a wife from a mail-order catalogue.
Logged
brassbandmaestro
*****
Gender: Male
Posts: 2216


The ties that bind


« Reply #1 on: 12:04:37, 14-10-2007 »

Thank you evryone for your advice/opinions. I will defionetily not go for the Bose then, maybe a seperates system. I might've been a bit too ambitious with the price range there!

The alternative would be seperates. I live in the Brighton & Hove area,(near to), so wouldnt be a problem to getting down there and looking at various retail shops. Could anyone advise me at all on this? I probably would have a buget of say £500 - £700.
Logged
Barebodkin
*
Posts: 21


« Reply #2 on: 12:06:13, 14-10-2007 »

Of course, how silly of me to have thought that piling CD's on top of each other would work, I must have been thinking of the old record player autochangers that altered the angle of the stylus and degraded the sound each time a record was added!

I think that your reasoning is spot on, and I see no point other than as a gimmick for a Cd autochanger.

And yes, I have purchsed sperate items of Hi Fi equipment from different smaller maufacturers in Britain, which give superb sound, and are much better than the multinational companies products.

BB
Logged
Barebodkin
*
Posts: 21


« Reply #3 on: 12:10:20, 14-10-2007 »

Thank you evryone for your advice/opinions. I will defionetily not go for the Bose then, maybe a seperates system. I might've been a bit too ambitious with the price range there!

The alternative would be seperates. I live in the Brighton & Hove area,(near to), so wouldnt be a problem to getting down there and looking at various retail shops. Could anyone advise me at all on this? I probably would have a buget of say £500 - £700.

What would you need to buy? An amp, a CD player, and speakers?

It would be hard to get all of those for £700 I'm afraid. More like £1100 to £1200? Maybe Ron would have a good idea about price, or perhaps quality secondhand gear?
Logged
brassbandmaestro
*****
Gender: Male
Posts: 2216


The ties that bind


« Reply #4 on: 12:13:00, 14-10-2007 »

Thank you evryone for your advice/opinions. I will defionetily not go for the Bose then, maybe a seperates system. I might've been a bit too ambitious with the price range there!

The alternative would be seperates. I live in the Brighton & Hove area,(near to), so wouldnt be a problem to getting down there and looking at various retail shops. Could anyone advise me at all on this? I probably would have a buget of say £500 - £700.

What would you need to buy? An amp, a CD player, and speakers?

It would be hard to get all of those for £700 I'm afraid. More like £1100 to £1200? Maybe Ron would have a good idea about price, or perhaps quality secondhand gear?
Ah right ok. What about those complete in built systems then like Sony do for example, anyone please?
Logged
Barebodkin
*
Posts: 21


« Reply #5 on: 12:40:47, 14-10-2007 »


Thank you evryone for your advice/opinions. I will defionetily not go for the Bose then, maybe a seperates system. I might've been a bit too ambitious with the price range there!


Quote
Ah right ok. What about those complete in built systems then like Sony do for example, anyone please?

Well, I don't think personally that they are very good, at least for good sound. Sony, I suppose might be OK - but a rather limited sound quality, and some other makes would be quite poor.

But others who have experience of these systems should advise here as well.
Logged
brassbandmaestro
*****
Gender: Male
Posts: 2216


The ties that bind


« Reply #6 on: 12:52:08, 14-10-2007 »

So what with my budget of, as I said earlier of £500 - £700, what sort of equipment would be best.
Logged
Ron Dough
Admin/Moderator Group
*****
Posts: 5133



WWW
« Reply #7 on: 12:55:46, 14-10-2007 »

BBM,

It's taken a while to write this, meanwhile other posts have appeared: however...

The sensible place to start would be at Richer Sounds, who have a Brighton Branch: though in the interests of choice, there are two other dealer chains with a great reputation also located there: Audio-T and Sevenoaks. I have no links with Richer, other than being a very satisfied customer of many years' standing, and I have had dealings with both of the other two, having indeed actually worked for one of them for a short while after it took over the independent store where I had worked on-and-off for the best part of two decades; you're spoilt for choice round there. When it comes to the built-in systems from the big names, then the caveat I've mentioned before about the advertising budget probably applies, by the way.

http://www.richersounds.com/information.php?cda=locationdetails&locationid=39

http://www.audio-t.co.uk/?section=stores&page=stores&id=4

http://www.sevenoakssoundandvision.co.uk/store.asp?id=12

Although you've given us your budget, you've not as yet told us what you want for that. I'm guessing CD, Amp, Tuner and Speakers. Correct? Richer handle the Cambridge range - British owned and designed, though built abroad, and if you're considering full sized separates, that's certainly where I'd start: a couple of years ago I helped an elderly friend of mine who had had very high-end equipment in the seventies and was moving to a much smaller house find a new system. He'd actually bought one of the Bose units as a replacement, and although he still has it, it's now in the kitchen, because it's acceptable there whilst he found it disappointing in the main room. Since he can no longer get out and about much, and I had supplied much of his original equipment in the days when I still worked part-time in retail Hi-Fi, he asked if I would help him build a new system, not too big, not too expensive, which would go some way to recreating what he'd loved about his big set-up. We ended up with a Cambridge amp and Cd player, which are really wonderful value, and once they've run-in (the better a piece of kit, the longer it takes to stabilise) convey a good sense of what's on the discs without calling attention to themselves. I'd guess that the other two stores are going to be fairly hard-pressed to compete with separates in that price range, but give them a try. Richers can get a little frantic at times, but see if you can book a demonstration, which you'll certainly be able to do at the other two. Take two or three favourite discs with you - contrasted material from more than one genre, label and era if possible, and be prepared to let them do the rest, though be firm about what you want (i.e. if you're not intending to go audio-visual then stop them demonstrating that) and how much you're prepared to pay - do remember though that there will be extras: cables and speaker leads, and very possibly speaker stands, too.

Speakers are a very much more personal choice: I know what I like at virtually every price level, but am very aware that my ears have different preferences to many others; when I first started, there was one top-selling loudspeaker I couldn't bear to listen to; it didn't stop me selling them to those who loved them, after all it was their money and their choice, but I never understood what endeared them to the majority. There is a Richer deal now where speakers come free with a Cambridge amp and CD player at around £500; one possibility would be to go for that package now and look at better speakers later if you find those supplied don't suit you. But it is your choice. Let others guide, but your ears decide.
« Last Edit: 12:59:24, 14-10-2007 by Ron Dough » Logged
Andy D
*****
Posts: 3061



« Reply #8 on: 13:01:26, 14-10-2007 »

Re amplifiers: I'm currently looking at buying a second amp for use in my computer room. My main amp is an Audiolab 8000A which is now 20 years old and still performing wonderfully.

I've been looking at the Cambridge Audio range and the Azur 340A seems to be pretty good for what I want it for. £150 from Richer Sounds. Any thoughts? Might be the sort of thing you're looking for bbm?

(This discussion is all a bit off topic, perhaps it can be adjourned to http://r3ok.myforum365.com/index.php?board=18.0?)

Only just seen your post Ron - snap!
Logged
Ron Dough
Admin/Moderator Group
*****
Posts: 5133



WWW
« Reply #9 on: 13:23:31, 14-10-2007 »

Andy, yes, we need to move this all to a more relevant location, agreed.

The elderly friend I mentioned earlier (not above, note) has a 340. A really nice machine, very good for the money. I liked it so much that I've bought a 540 for the study here. A tad on the warmer and richer (no pun intended) side of neutral than your Audiolab (which is to my ears about the same distance the other side of neutral) it is none the less a very musical beast, faithfully representing what's fed into it - quite competent at showing the differences between quite expensive CD players for example. The more powerful 540A with the CD player as well - and that really is several strides ahead of most of the similarly priced competition at the offer price - strikes me as a really sensible place to start for a main system, allowing for a greater variety of speakers to be driven satisfactorily.

 Don't forget that greater amplifier power isn't just for going louder, but allowing more headroom for musical peaks at the same playing level, in exactly the same way that a car with greater horsepower will have better acceleration than a more lowly one, even when staying within a given speed limit. I'm aware that BBM tends to listen to quite large-scale music, and am surmising that his system will need plenty in hand to be able to launch forth properly into those great crescendi....
Logged
brassbandmaestro
*****
Gender: Male
Posts: 2216


The ties that bind


« Reply #10 on: 13:35:27, 14-10-2007 »

Ive been enquiring about the purchase of HI Fi equipment on 'The Happy Room' thread. Obviously the wrong place. So if youve any hints and tips, I be most grateful. Already some people have said about some retailers and types of equipment. But I am all ears!!
Logged
Andy D
*****
Posts: 3061



« Reply #11 on: 13:59:45, 14-10-2007 »

Ron suggested the Azur 540 which Richer do for £250 as opposed to £150 for the 340. When I were a lad  Cheesy, a rough guide used to be spend 1/3rd of your budget on each of amp, speakers, CD player (I'm sure Ron will correct me if my memory is faulty). Plus you've got to get cables etc so the 540 is pushing you above your stated range of £500-700. If you want a tuner as well, you've definitely got to go for the 340. But either will sound much better than any complete system.

Do try to listen if you can. When I bought my Audiolab in 1987, I listened to it against some other amps, using the same speakers and CD player, and was amazed at the difference in the sound. Having settled on the amp, I then compared CD players and finally speakers, which are the hardest thing to choose and do depend on what sort of music you listen to.

I've always found Richer to be pretty good and have bought several audio items from them, although avoid going in at the busy times eg lunchtime, Saturday.
Logged
Ron Dough
Admin/Moderator Group
*****
Posts: 5133



WWW
« Reply #12 on: 14:33:32, 14-10-2007 »

If we're in the £700 bracket, then the offer here:

http://www.richersounds.com/information.php?cda=static&cst=hifisystems,

could still form the basis, Andy, though if BBM needs to drop down, then I'd rather it was on the amp than the CD player: the equal division of cost between items isn't something I'd necessarily agree with in any case: it normally needs to be biased towards the source: using the gigo principle (garbage in, garbage out) then the best system in the world would be absolutely useless if fed by a rubbish CD player, whilst a basic system fed by a higher-grade player will have every chance of giving of its best. The combo of the two better items with the free speakers means that even with a tuner added in,

http://www.richersounds.com/showproduct.php?cda=showproduct&pid=CAMB-AZUR640T-BLK

 we could just about come in at the £700 mark, and leave a good upgrade path for better speakers later, while giving pretty good sound for now.

I must of course reiterate that these are only suggestions, and that BBM will hopefully go his own way when the time comes to chose.
Logged
brassbandmaestro
*****
Gender: Male
Posts: 2216


The ties that bind


« Reply #13 on: 17:38:54, 14-10-2007 »

Hey  there people. Ive thought about these items. What do you reckon:

Cambridge Audio:

£249.95 /Azur 640A V2(black)
Logged
brassbandmaestro
*****
Gender: Male
Posts: 2216


The ties that bind


« Reply #14 on: 17:44:14, 14-10-2007 »

I forgot to put in Cambridge Audio 640C(black)(£249.95).

The other items I would need is speakers, leads, headphones, speaker stands. As I said before I will not be neeing a tuner, thankfully!! So that would spread my budget a bit more.
Logged
Pages: [1] 2
  Print  
 
Jump to: