Shostakovich, Symphony No.13 Babi Yar
How does this compare to the Haitink recording? I bought all the Haitink versions about a decade ago, thinking they may not be the best all-around, but at least of a consistent level of quality. This was back when I was far more interested in composers than in interpreters.
I'm enjoying the Maxim S set and think that the Prague SO have retained something of the Eastern European sound, whereas Haitink's Concertgebouw sounds just a little too smooth/ cultured, especially after you've heard Kondrashin. Peter Mikuláš is a fine soloist, as is Rintzler for Haitink. I rather like Anatoli Kotscherga, who is the bass soloist for Neeme Järvi on DG, where the biting sarcasm in his voice is great.
Has anyone heard Mark Wigglesworth's Babi Yar or the recording by the Beethoven Orchester, Bonn under Roman Hofman on MDG? I've read some good things about them.