I'd certainly vote for Perkins too - she had it sorted. I'd actually like her to win on this evidence.
Oddly enough while Soul was painful, I did think that he at least seems vaguely musical, unlike Walsh who was too vacuous to cause pain - just extreme irritation. Frankly, I thought Asher was lucky to survive the axe tonight.
Of the others, Derham was efficient
There's something horribly punchable about Katie Derham - she's too clinical and pointy and she manages to get a very bland response from the orchestra every time. She just doesn't seem to have any discernable personality.
David Soul I find very creepy. In the first episode when his mentor was getting him to act a story I had to hide behind a cushion, it was worse than a lot of horror films.
I'm very disappointed in Alex James, it's a bit like watching your dad dancing embarrassingly at a wedding or something. I rather liked the comment "I'm not sure what you're left arm is doing, did you want a cup of coffee?" "Yes."
I too was delighted to see Asher come a cropper. How mean are we all?
Go Perkins.
Where's Giles Coren in all this then? Maybe he's tone deaf. I'd like to see Stephen Fry give it a go as well. Maybe one for Maestro 2: the Remake