I finally got to GIOCONDA this evening. Peter Robinson gave a suave and italianate reading of the score, coaxing decent playing out of the orchestra (for a welcome change) - although he can't make the fiddles play in tune. Gweneth-Ann Jeffers did well in "Suicido", but failed to bring that focus to the rest of the role... there's a lot of unburnt petrol in what she produces. Olafur Sigardurson tended to blast as Barnaba, and although very audible, it was very samey throughout - the line gets quite chopped up. I must confess to knowing Zaplechny personally, so I shall sadly pass over his performance.
But the production was the most wretched pile of bilge I've seen in years - it's this kind of thing that gets opera a bad name
Yes, there was a solution to the problem of the boats - but that's all there was. Monotonous, clicheed, static, and relying on tired formulae which contribute nothing to the story-telling at all. Under-directed performers tend to over-correct by adding too much and hamming it - and that's what happened.